Over the last few days, I’ve written a lot of things that give the impression that I’m a Christian. It’s Easter, that happens.
But I’m actually quite uncomfortable with it.
There is a massive part of me, that in spite of being a practising Christian happy to share with people and keen to hear from them, is terribly afraid that people will find out. Terribly afraid.
On the occasions where folk say to me ‘oh yeah, I figured you would be’, I take it not as a compliment – that maybe I am living the faith I’d like – but with deepest suspicion. Shameful as it itself is, I recoil. What does that mean you think of me? What in the way I acted gave you the idea that I was one of them?
I’ll be honest, probably not the best attitude to have. Particularly if one is a synod youth rep for a major British denomination. But I do. I do, and not necessarily without reason. Perhaps without good reason, but I find it hard to let go the idea.
I am ashamed to be called Christian. And not because I’m ashamed of what I believe. I’ll sit and talk you silly, explore things, explain things – I’m a bloody theology student. I’m involved in the church. I’m not afraid for people to know I’m Christian, but I’m ashamed of what that means.
I’m ashamed. Not just because the church gets a bad rap, but because it bloody deserves one.
I’m ashamed to be part of a hypocritical faith. I’m ashamed to own up to belonging when there’s so much I detest. I’m ashamed that when people know I’m a Christian, they’re less likely to see Christ in me.
I’m proud of many things as well. Culturally, personally, spiritually. But how can I share those things?
When people hear I’m a Christian, what does that say? I come from a very different angle and attitude to the majority of Christians I know. And not because of what I was taught, but what that taught me to believe. The influence of others has been monumental – but I can safely say, rightly or wrongly, that most of what I’ve learned is what I won’t be like, not of examples I can follow. I know that people who perceive me as Christian put me in a box. Equally so, those who are Christians themselves. How many people in the church have stopped to ask me what I think, what I believe, how I see things? They assume we’re seeing the same. Because Christians are, right? We’re all one in Christ?
But that’s the jews and the gentiles. The slaves and the free. And one hell of a lot of different ways to see things and know God. How can we assume what anyone understands? How can the perception of a mass affect so much?
I’m ashamed to be associated with a faith from which so many bad things have come. From crusades to witch-hunts to unjust law in the name of God. I’m far more ashamed to be part of a faith from which so many bad things come every single day. A faith which hates, excludes, judges, and hurts. And all so un-necessarily. Because I think that every Christian, when taken a step back and asked honestly, would say that it was wrong. Not that they don’t have a point, but I think people skew religion an awful lot. And would recognise that.
I describe myself as a bad Christian. Because, by most definitions, I am. But not for a second do I think that matters. I’m a horrifically fluffy liberal, so a lot of this is perhaps not unexpected, but it’s not my place to care.
I don’t think I’m right to support gay rights, abortion, a man-written view of the Bible, rights to death, evolution, progression of most things, and a million others the church tells me is wrong. I think those things because I don’t know how to not. I could be so very wrong. But that’s the case for everyone. Not matter what you believe, no matter how much you can back it up, it is still only a belief and you are most probably wrong somewhere. That’s the beauty, I think, but it’s a cause of so much tension. There’re many things that just I don’t share with people who know me as Christian, because the judgement would boot me right out of the church.
More than once, I’ve openly admitted to being Christian. Only to be told ‘No, you’re not!’.
Hell. And I’m downright ashamed to admit that I believe this. That I believe the same things that justify all this. I’m ashamed that people will think I do exactly the same as they expect. And I’m ashamed that I could. Maybe I should be ashamed that I do.
I don’t want to be a Christian. But I don’t want to renounce my faith. If describing myself as Christian meant what it meant to me, it would make life a lot easier. Because, dammit, being thought of as Christian gets in the way. But our language doesn’t support individuals. Maybe I shouldn’t be ashamed, but I am.